Mystery Lake Fishing near Pagosa Springs, Colorado

Mystery Lake is a lake located just 31.5 miles from Pagosa Springs, in Archuleta County, in the state of Colorado, United States, near Cumbres, CO. Fishermen will find a variety of fish including cutthroat trout and others here. Whether you’re fly fishing or otherwise your chances of getting a bite here are good. So grab your favorite fly fishing rod and reel, and head out to Mystery Lake.

Join us as we discuss the Colorado Fishing License options, fishing rules and fishing regulations. Please remember to check with the local Fish and Wildlife department to ensure the stream is open to the public. Now get out there and fish! Check out our Fishing Times chart to determine when the fish will be most active.

  "Artificial flies and lures only. Trout limit of 2. Fair fishing for sizable rainbow and brown trout...." Middle Fork Piedra River

  "Decent trout inhabit Plumtaw Creek in good enough numbers to warrant at least an exploratory trip...." Plumtaw Creek

  "The East Fork of the Piedra River is 9ft wide and 10 miles long. The East Fork is wadable. Fly..." East Fork Piedra River